Cowboys Insider's Unexpected NFL Draft Prospects: Names To Watch

Benjamin Cohen

4 min read

Post on Apr 25, 2025

4.0

Share

Under-the-Radar Offensive Weapons

The Cowboys' offense needs a spark, and that spark might come from some unexpected NFL Draft prospects flying under the radar. This section focuses on two key areas where hidden talent abounds.

Small-School Standouts

Small colleges are often breeding grounds for underrated talent. These players may lack the national exposure of their Power Five counterparts, but their skills are undeniable. Looking at these sleeper picks could yield significant returns for Dallas.

• Jamarion Miller, WR, Shepherd University: Miller boasts blazing speed (4.3 40-yard dash) and exceptional route-running ability. While playing against lesser competition, his production was outstanding, showcasing the potential for a significant offensive upgrade. His small-school status makes him an unexpected NFL Draft prospect with significant upside. This kind of "offensive potential" is precisely what the Cowboys need.
• Antoine Johnson, RB, Northwestern State: Johnson is a powerful runner with surprising agility for his size. He consistently exceeded expectations in a run-heavy offense, proving his ability to carry the load. His "underrated talent" makes him a compelling late-round option.

Players with Injury History (But High Upside)

Sometimes, the best value comes with a bit of risk. Players with injury histories can offer a "high-reward, high-upside" proposition if their recovery goes well. The Cowboys' medical staff will be crucial in evaluating these "comeback story" candidates.

• Devonte Smith, CB, University of Florida: Smith possesses elite athleticism and coverage skills but missed significant time with a knee injury. His talent is undeniable; the Cowboys must carefully assess the "injury risk" before selecting him. A successful recovery could make him a steal.
• Isaiah Thomas, OL, Oklahoma State: A back injury hampered Thomas's senior season, but his film from previous years showcases exceptional pass protection and run blocking skills. He offers significant "high-upside" potential as a developmental prospect.

Defensive Gems Flying Under the Radar

The Cowboys’ defense needs bolstering, and focusing on overlooked defensive talent could be the key. This section highlights two areas of particular interest.

Versatile Defensive Backs

Versatility is king in today's NFL, and finding defensive backs who can excel at multiple positions is crucial. This "secondary depth" can make a huge difference.

• Caleb Farley, CB/S, Virginia Tech: While injury concerns exist, Farley's athleticism and ball skills are exceptional. His ability to play both cornerback and safety adds to his value as a potential "draft steal" for a team needing "defensive versatility."
• Jordan Battle, S, Alabama: Battle isn't necessarily an "unexpected" prospect, but his value lies in his consistency and all-around skills. He's a strong tackler, good in coverage, and provides much-needed leadership in the secondary, making him a solid addition to improve "secondary depth."

Pass-Rushing Specialists with Unique Attributes

Edge rushers are always in high demand. Finding "impact players" with unique pass-rushing abilities can significantly impact the team's success, even if they aren't the top-ranked prospects. The Cowboys need to find that hidden gem.

• Will McDonald IV, Edge, Iowa State: McDonald's speed and relentless pursuit make him a nightmare for opposing quarterbacks. While his size might be considered a minor concern, his "pass rusher" skills are elite. His "edge defender" capabilities make him a valuable asset.
• Nick Hampton, LB/Edge, Appalachian State: Hampton is a smaller linebacker with exceptional speed and instincts. He often uses his unique skill set to overcome size disadvantages and excels as a "linebacker talent" with remarkable pass-rushing skills.

Late-Round Surprises with Pro Potential

Finding "value picks" and "late-round steals" is crucial for any NFL team hoping to build a strong roster. These "hidden gems" can turn into significant contributors.

• Tyjae Spears, RB, Tulane: Spears is a dynamic runner who could slip to the later rounds due to his size. However, his elusiveness and ability to make big plays make him a "potential for growth" player that is worth looking at.
• Cameron Mitchell, CB, Louisiana: Mitchell has the skillset to play at the next level but could fall because of the depth at the corner position. The Cowboys may find great "value picks" in later rounds if they focus on players like him.

Conclusion

This insider's look at unexpected NFL Draft prospects offers a glimpse into potential game-changers for the Dallas Cowboys. From small-school standouts to players with injury histories, there’s a wealth of “underrated NFL prospects” and "NFL draft sleepers" waiting to be discovered. These players could bring significant value, proving that sometimes, the best finds are the ones you least expect. Stay tuned for further updates on the Cowboys' draft strategy and keep an eye on these unexpected NFL Draft prospects as the draft unfolds. Don't miss out on the potential "Cowboys draft picks" that could redefine the team's future!